Fire Island NY Hotels - Picking the Right Hotel with us

Welcome to Fire Island, NY

Come and stay awhile.

Fire Island Hotels

Accommodations fill quickly on Fire Island and only a few towns offer hotel and inn options . The accommodations are charming, but don’t expect a plethora of planned activities or five star ratings. This secluded island is all about defining your own fun at the beach.

Picking the right hotel on Fire Island starts with picking the location that suits your lifestyle. Many Fire Island visitors are looking for either hotels in the gay resort destination of The Pines and Grove or the more family oriented and straight singles areas of Ocean Beach. These areas also offer the bulk of the island's nightlife and hotel accommodations.

Cherry Grove

Belvedere Guest House for Men

Fire-Island-NY-Belvedere-Pines-Hotel

Fire Island’s premier accommodation, the Belvedere Guest House for Men, is located on the bay front at Cherry Grove near Fire Island Pines just a few minutes from one of the world’s best beaches.

 

Dune Point Guest House

Historic Dune Point is the only oceanfront guest house in Cherry Grove, Fire Island, a paradise beach community without roads or vehicles. This quaint town is connected only by wooden walkways, giving it a serene magical feel like no other place you have ever experienced

Grove Hotel

Are you looking to be right next to the party? This place is steps away from the Ice Palace and the hotel is certainly convenient to downtown. However, be aware that this is no Hilton; be prepared for tidy, cinder-block, dormitory-style rooms and bedsheets that are changed only upon request.

Ocean Beach

Fire Island Hotel & Resort

This secluded spot at the end of Cayuga Walk offers a great location as it sits on the sand dune overlooking the ocean. The accommodations are modest and vary in cabins, studios, and guest suites. Just steps from the ocean, this complex boasts a pool, patio, and bar and grill. Singles flock here on weekends to take advantage of the Ocean Bay Park party scene.

Blue Waters Hotel

The Blue Waters Hotel is big enough yet intimate enough for all our guests to receive the personal attention you would expect from Fire Island’s unique boutique hotel. All rooms have flat screen TV’s with DVD, cable, air conditioning, and Wi-Fi.

Cleggs Hotel

The Clegg family has been in the Fire Island hotel service since 1946. The Clegg’s Hotel was built to resemble a sailor’s rooming house. The accommodations are modest and styled after a European boarding house. Studios offer water or garden views and private baths, whereas single rooms overlook the garden and share baths.

Houser's Hotel

At this 1921 colonial-style inn, bay breezes and marina views characterize that classic Fire Island feel. Rooms, furnished in a simple country style, are airy, and overlook the Great South Bay. The real appeal to this hotel is the Hideaway Restaurant and Houser’s Bar on the complex. Guests looking to enjoy a simpler way of life value their stay at Houser’s Hotel.

The Palms Hotel - Fire Island

This plush boutique resort boasts two locations centered in the village of Ocean Beach. Popular for the luxurious accommodations, the rooms at the Palms are bright and meticulously tended to. They are furnished with the finest amenities including: flat screen TV, Wi-Fi, ipod accessibility, and a refrigerator. The customer service is friendly and incredibly efficient.

Seasons Bed & Breakfast

Cozy and romantic, this country home by the sea is decorated with window flower baskets. The picnic tables on the patio encourage guests to loosen up and bask in the sun at this in-town bed and breakfast. Rooms are clean and comfortable and tempered with that northeast beach flavor.

Fire Island Pines

Botel

Located in the center of the commercial district, guests enjoy the privilege of staying steps away from all the restaurants, bars, cafes, shops, and, of course, the beautiful beach. As a tribute to its rich history, we bid adieu to the Hotel Ciel name, reinstating the Botel identity which it held since its construction in 1960.

The Madison - Fire Island Pines

The acclaimed Madison Fire Island Pines is different from anything you’ve ever experienced in this famed gay community. The Advocate recommends it as the best place to stay in the Pines, and raves about its “chic” accommodations. Stylish and modern, it’s a place where flat-screen televisions, high-speed internet service, and massages by the pool are just the beginning.

Pines Place

The acclaimed Madison Fire Island Pines is different from anything you’ve ever experienced in this famed gay community. The Advocate recommends it as the best place to stay in the Pines, and raves about its “chic” accommodations. Stylish and modern, it’s a place where flat-screen televisions, high-speed internet service, and massages by the pool are just the beginning.

Ocean Bay Park

Seashore Condo Motel

This two-story motel is located in the center of town, steps from the dining and nightlife Ocean Bay Park is famous for. Conveniently located to the beach, bay, and ferry the Sea Shore Condo Motel provides a comfortable stay. Each room features air conditioning, private bath, color TV, and a kitchenette with access to a barbecue grill.