Accommodations fill quickly on Fire Island and only a few towns offer hotel and inn options . The accommodations are charming, but don’t expect a plethora of planned activities or five star ratings. This secluded island is all about defining your own fun at the beach.

Picking the right hotel on Fire Island starts with picking the location that suits your lifestyle. Many Fire Island visitors are looking for either hotels in the Gay resort destination of The Pines and Grove or the more family oriented and straight singles area of Ocean Beach. These areas also offer the bulk of the islands nightlife and hotel accommodations.

Cherry Grove

Davis Park

Fair Harbor

Fire Island Pines

Kismet

Ocean Bay Park

Ocean Beach

Sayville

Watch Hill