Although Ocean Beach has a more impressive selection of restaurants, you certainly don’t want to pass up the Pines Bistro and Martini Bar if you are looking for the ultimate dining experience. Known for its intimate style of dining, the Pines Bistro is the premier Italian restaurant on Fire Island. It may not be the easiest to locate at first but the reviews speak for themselves. Their food and service are fantastic—their call to fame is their martinis. The total cost can range anywhere from $40 to $100 per person depending on how many drinks you order.
Arguably this pick should be higher on the list but due to its less convenient location, it gets a lower spot. Located in Cherry Grove, the Top of the Bay restaurant is the place to be for a sunset dinner. […]